The foam ring is for under the sink. Silicon offers many advantages over standard plumbers putty. Today we have decided, instead of focusing on just one huge plumber putty brand, to focus on three of the largest. the replacement assembly I just bought includes a rubber gasket to be used as an alternative to plumbers putty. Then the tub-drain unit screws into the drain from inside the tub to make the connection. It is up to you to find out whether you want one that dries clear or one that dries with a white finish. With the rubber gasket used instead of the putty, I had a little gap to fill. Author: Anonymous User Most acrylic or gelcoat tubs or showers recommend to install the drain assembly according to the drain manufacturers recommendations. It has been manufactured by LDR Industries. I recently had a new brushed aluminum sink install and retrofitted the plumbing. You would use plumbers' putty or silicone on the flange. You probably have a mis-alignment somewhere, or trash under the rubber gasket that wou't let it seat, or something similar. Last update on 2021-01-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API, PlumbingLove.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to Amazon.com, Plumber putty can sometimes be a nuisance to handle, and you may be looking for a more workable solution for installing drains, or other plumbing fixes. If you are a beginner to using a plumber putty alternative, this LDR product comes with an easy installation instruction manual, so you won’t do anything wrong. Tubes that can be hung up are very beneficial when trying to tidy up your garage area. Fortunately, none of the piping below the tub cracked or shattered. Since the drain side is not under any real pressure, it's just a gravity flow, the plumbers putty is usually more tham enough to keep the water in the pipes. The adhesive is made of silicon rubber, for easy usage and to hold tight. Re: bathtub drain, putty or silicone? Re: Tub drain and plumbers putty; Author: dlh (TX) as a business owner i am going to look at anything incidental to the task that took me to the house and anything the customer mentions and give them my professional recommendations. Usually underneath there is a rubber gasket and sometimes a paper gasket. Don’t do it. i did not put any dope/tape around the male threading of the basket as 1) the instructions didn't ask for it and 2) there is a rubber gasket between the part that goes immediately into the hole on the inside the tub (inside meaning which can't be seen) and i thought the gasket … I can't stand silicone. I'll look for "heavy duty" when I go to pick up the PVC glue. The overflow tub secures to the top with screws through the cover plate that grabs the overflow tube. When used, it resists shrinking by any means so you can feel good once a job is complete. Current Best Selling Plumber Putty # It comes in a compact 9-ounce tube that measures 6” by 1” by 1”. Rubber gasket on bottom and putty around drain flange. Before you dive in, it's important to familiarize yourself with a tub drain system. It has a really smooth flow for consistent placement during a job. I'm sure I don't have it tight enough but I'm worried about cracking the acrylic tub (veritek; Swanstone Tub BT 3060). I first used plumbers putty to install the strainer basket. That is unless plumbers putty will cause damage to their unit, then you will see a warning notice with the tub documentation not to use plumbers putty. This video will show you how to replace a bathtub drain shoe gasket. Use a rubber gasket, instead of plumbers putty, when installing a sink strainer basket on a brushed aluminum sink. I'll avoid putting anything on the threads. What is plumbers putty? If the drain is rotating, that is likely the reason people are getting leaks using putty. As you can see putty was used on the gasket. No putty required here. Instead of using plumbers putty, I used a rubber gasket, then placed the strainer over it, installed the rubber and paper gasket, plus the metal tightening ring from underneath . That being said, the products themselves work outstandingly and are great to have around the home. A tight seal. I tightened some more but dont want to over tighten and have the thing crack. The nut on the bottom side rotates. Plumbers putty is most often used to put together sinks and seal them to prevent water leaks. First on our list today is the LDR 502 7200 Tub Caulk, another alternative for plumber putty. Use a rubber gasket, instead of plumbers putty, when installing a sink strainer basket on a brushed aluminum sink. The disposal I bought (GE) says not to use plumbers putty on a stainless steel sink install (putty to be used on other sinks) and to use a rubber gasket it came with. My first question is do I still need to use plumbers putty on the new drain threads if it comes with a rubber gasket? Good luck. Plumber’s putty is one of the basics tools in a plumber's tool bag. So far, so good. Sink Drain Rubber Gasket Or Plumbers Putty. Replace The Drain … Some people use pipe dope on the drain threads, I don't. The Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive is the second product on our list today and is another best plumber putty alternative. Plumber putty can sometimes be a nuisance to handle, and you may be looking for a more workable solution for installing drains, or other plumbing fixes. They would benefit from having a larger tube to choose from so you can buy in bulk. This allows you to have a wide spectrum to choose from, especially since there are thousands of alternatives of plumber putties available on the market today. Why is plumber's putty needed? However, I want to make sure I reinstall it correctly. They create high-end products that work, at a fraction of the cost of similar products. I recently had a new brushed aluminum sink install and retrofitted the plumbing. Plumbers use it because it remains soft for a long time and maintains a watertight seal, but unlike silicone and other types of caulk, plumber's putty is not an adhesive, so a fixture or drain part sealed with putty remains easy to remove if … This allows a plumber, or you, to remove the drain when you want to replace it. This is why they have made quite the name for themselves throughout the plumbing community. As a Licence Master Plumber, I use plumbers putty all the time to seal drains in sinks and baths. The gasket doesn't fit into the hole of the bowl either and it's tapered, to seal the bottom. I watched a video that said silicone was better than plumbers putty. Rubber goes on first. As the diagram at right above shows, the flange is held in place with a threaded connection to the drain elbow (aka drain shoe). That is unless plumbers putty will cause damage to their unit, then you will see a warning notice with the tub documentation not to use plumbers putty. The original installation did not include a rubber seal. The common theme between the three products with the con is that these tubes simply don’t come with enough product. The putty goes between the top portion of the tub and the metal drain that goes into the drain and the rubber gasket goes under the tub between the tub and the female portion of the drain kit. You want the drain portion to pull down evenly as the nut is firmed up from below. Take the time to make sure what you are using is rated for it and you will have a good seal that can be serviced instead of a one time shot that complicates future work. well the f*cking thing is leaking at the drain nut. As you can see putty was used on the gasket. Add a header to begin generating the table of contents. - Answered by a verified Plumber. 1. scoop out a couple quarter size chunks of plumbers putty. I'd like some opinions on replacing the pop-up drain flange on my bathroom sink. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, Don't advertise or try to compare pricing, thanks, Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. Thank you! Very brief instructions simply mention that rubber gasket for tub drain goes between tub & drain (inside tub). The main substitution comes from silicone-based products as you’ll see below. i will not tell them they need something they really don't. What makes this product so great is that it dries transparent, making it easier to use it places, without it becoming an eye sore. When I took the old drain apart, I did have a bunch of pipe putty in that area. Same is true when using plumber's putty. (personally I prefer the plumbers putty because once a basket is set in with silicone it is nearly impossible to ever remove again, and contrary to public opinion, silicone will leak in time due to the minor flexing of the tub … It has can seal leaks around the home. Even when the water is coming down the top of the drain, it can still make it out of those holes, into the area that you think you would be protecting with the rubber gasket or plumbers putty. Sealing an existing or new drain basket is easily done with plumber's putty. Required fields are marked *. Working in the area beneath your tub, tighten the nut below the tub to pull the underside of the drain lip firmly against the surface of the tub. Your email address will not be published. The bath tub … 0 Comment. I put it all together, used plumbers putty and molded across as seen on other diy yt videos, placed the rubber gasket, some plumbers tape on the thread and then tightened the drain nut. I’m a happy man. Hope this helps. Some plumbers and installers favor plumber's putty for installing drains, while others lean toward the more modern waterproof material called silicone caulk. The section of piping below the tub did include a rubber gasket between the PVC flange and tub bottom. This alternative to plumber putty comes in a 2.7-ounce tube for bonding aluminum, brick, ceramic, glass, leather, many plastics, rubber, steel, wood, and cardboard. This alternative putty product is actually siliconized acrylic-latex caulk to be used instead of putty. However. The section of piping below the tub did include a rubber gasket between the PVC flange and tub bottom. Plumbers putty is the go-to solution in plumbing projects but you need to know how to use plumbers putty first. I was able to remove it with a drain extractor, but it was so tight that the section of PVC plumbing below the drain began to spin and wrenched free. By Doni Anto | December 16, 2018. Apply a fresh ring of plumbers putty. Comparing my other sinks - they have a flat rubber gasket closing off the bottom of the bowl, with a thin nut securing it to the bottom of the bowl. Use the product below instead. This caulk from LDR has a white finish after using it. Your email address will not be published. Within time the putty hardened, the metal ring under the basket … If you have a tile that is loose, this adhesive has been built to secure it back in place. The material is durable, flexible, resistant to any mildew, and waterproof—which is great for leaks. Silicon offers many advantages over standard plumbers putty. This last product has been developed by Oatey. Why Use Plumber's Putty . The product comes in an 8-ounce tube, but it also can be hung up. Install a new gasket by sliding it between the drain shoe and the tub. 2. roll the putty … In this episode of Repair and Replace, Vance shows how to properly use plumber's putty on a bathroom sink drain. The original installation did not include a rubber seal. It does help. The reason plumbers decide to use putty is that it has been designed to remain soft for a long period, without breaking that watertight seal. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. The rubber washer goes on that PVC tub shoe. Flexible, durable, extremely mildew-resistant, waterproof. Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), GE Sealants & Adhesives 281 Advanced Silicone 2 Kitchen & Bath Sealant,…, Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive, Oatey 25605 Hercules 6-Ounce White Tube Plumber’s Caulk, Best Pipe Clamps of 2021: Complete Reviews with Comparison, Best PVC Pipe Cutters of 2021: Best Picks, Best Plumbing Torch of 2021: Our Top Picks, Best Copper Pipe Cutter of 2021: Our Top Picks, Best Pipe Bender of 2021: Top Recommendations, The Best Utility Sinks for Your Laundry Room, 100% WATERPROOF: This 100% silicone formula offers ultimate protection from water damage, providing a…, 10-YEAR MOLD-FREE PRODUCT PROTECTION: Protects against stain-causing mold and mildew growth, 40% MORE FLEXIBILITY & 5X STRONGER ADHESION: Stays permanently flexible with a high-performing, durable…, 30-MINUTE WATER-READY: Ready for water exposure in as little as 30 minutes, Bonds aluminum, brick, cardboard, ceramic, fabric, fiberglass, glass, leather, most plastics, rubber,…, Great for sealing leaks, repairing tears, securing tiles, fixing footwear and mending glassware, Dries transparent for invisible repairs – dries gradually to allow time for repositioning. Outside of home care, it also can fix shoes and footwear, and mend your glasses back together in case of a break. Within time the putty hardened, the metal ring under the basket came loose and I had leakage. My plan is the rebuild this section of pipe, rather than trying to clean it for replacement. Though if you use a proper drain wrench, the drain should not be rotating. Leak from new bathroom sink drain pipe leak from new bathroom sink drain pipe bathroom sink drain installation. Seems like the original installer use plumbers putty on the flange and threads of the drain, apparently that why it was so hard to remove. The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. Roll a roll of plumber's putty about the size of a pencil and wrap it around the drain depression inside the bottom of the tub and tighten the drain lip down on it. That was filled with a small amount of putty around the circumference of the basket, then smoothed out. I won’t dive too deep into them here, but you can read more about itÂ. Can i use a rubber gasket in place of plumbers putty on my tub? Once it is dry however, it is watertight and leak resistant, making it one of the best substitutes to plumber putty on the market today. if i would let it go at my house i tell … Flows easily, does not harden in tube or cartridge, will not crumble, resists shrinkage. Bathtub drain installation... which way does the rubber gasket go.. underneath the drain hole tub or on top of drain - Answered by a verified Plumber. Between the underside of the flange and the tub surface, there's a good amount of plumbers putty that seals the inside of the drain. Squeeze out the putty into a thin rope that measures approximately a quarter-inch in diameter. Imgur Home owner here needing a little advice. Thank you good people. I first used plumbers putty to install the strainer basket. Make sure to use PVC heavy duty glue on the PVC piping when reconnecting it to the existing piping under the tub. Plumber’s putty is product that's used to seal drain bodies to tub surfaces. Siliconized acrylic-latex plumber’s caulk. Thanks. Clean off the excess putty and you should be good to go.Putty is just for the drain. In the last week I've had both a sink drain rubber washer and a tub drain rubber washer leak o n me. We can assure you that LDR Industries is a competitive standard for the best alternatives to plumber putties and they make high-end products that will work around your home. My first question is do I still need to use plumbers putty on the new drain threads if it comes with a rubber gasket? Use putty on the bottom of the drain flange, but not on the threads, Use the rubber gasket underneath the tub between the tub bottom and the PVC piping. Tip A clay-like substance called plumber's putty is the most popular choice for sealing sink drains, but you can also use silicone caulk. Remove any excess putty before it … Use 100% silicone caulk on the drain piece. Should putty be used if a rubber seal will also be installed? It is also at an incredibly affordable price. This last time? Loctite is another manufacturer that we trust, especially because of the attention to detail within their products. The main substitution comes from silicone-based products as you’ll see below. Flows easily, does not harden in tube or cartridge, will not crumble, resists shrinkage. It also has a drying method that takes its time, allowing you to re position something if it is not up to your satisfaction right away. It goes underneath between the shoe and the tub. take your finger (not your fingernail) and remove excess. If the drain is assembled correctly you … The instructions on the can of putty. I did find the install guide online and it says to use plumbers putty. If you know plumber putty, you know that Oatey is one of the best manufacturers for all things plumbing. The last plumber putty alternative up for review is the Oatey 25605 Hercules 6-Ounce White Tube Plumber’s Caulk. First clean all debris out of the area . In the past, I have always used plumbers putty between the flange and bowl. How to Putty a Shower Drain. I went through this twice. This takes the pressure off that you have to do it perfectly on the first try. GE Sealants & Adhesives 281 Advanced Silicone 2 Kitchen & Bath Sealant,... Loctite 1716864 Tube Plumber and Marine Adhesive, 2.7 Ounces, Oatey 25605 Hercules 6-Ounce White Tube Plumber's Caulk, Product no longer available. That water travels down a channel under the surface of the sink into the drain right through those big holes in the side of it. We use cookies to give you the best possible experience on our website. Place the putty beneath the loosened drain lip. Below the tub is the PVC drain and it comes with a rubber gasket. The drain is secured to the tub by screwing the drain basket down from inside the tub but requires sealant. I think I got it now. on the market right now, which is highly rated by plumbing professionals. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Today we are going to be looking at three alternative plumber putty products on the market right now, which is highly rated by plumbing professionals. Yes, that washer (or gasket) goes under the tub on top of the shoe. They are going to fix cracks in places you never thought possible and provide a strong hold which is resistant to water. Once you tighten up locking system, the putty will ooze out. Plumbers putty only seals when it is compressed into a thin layer under pressure to fill in any gaps between 2 smooth surfaces, sort of like teflon tape does for threaded fittings. I can leave my customer with a tub they can use immediately and not have to wait for something to cure, and have never had a problem with putty since we verify what we use on what. I’m going to assume you are installing either a pop-up assembly on a sink or a waste & overflow on a tub. When setting a new faucet, sink strainer or tub drain, use plumbers putty for inexpensive protection against … I won’t dive too deep into them here, but you can read more about it over here. If you use plumbers putty the drain can be used immediately but if you elect to use silicone you must allow 24 hours for the silicone to completely set. Inside the tube, this caulk will never harden and it does not crumble. Its main goal is to seal cracks throughout the home easily and efficiently in record-setting time. Most acrylic or gelcoat tubs or showers recommend to install the drain assembly according to the drain manufacturers recommendations. Bathroom lav pop-ups usually include a rubber gasket that goes between the finished flange of the pop-up and the sink. I needed to replace a broken bathtub drain. The new drain needs to have a fresh clean area to seat on with a healthy amount of plumbers putty. There's no mention of plumber's putty, so I guess just do as it says? It's not most putty, it's some. 6 Clean the drain opening on the tub with a rag and acetone to remove dirt, debris and old plumber's putty. Most putties have some petroleum products in them that will degrade plastics. i did put some plumbers putty on the downside of the flange of the drain basket. Hope it goes well for you Basket came loose and I had a new brushed aluminum sink install and the! It 's important to familiarize yourself with a rubber gasket they need something they really n't! Either a pop-up assembly on a brushed aluminum sink install and retrofitted the plumbing or showers recommend to install drain. Do I still need to use plumbers ' putty or silicone on the downside of the cost of products... People are getting leaks using putty that wou't let it seat tub drain rubber gasket or plumbers putty or under. Existing or new drain threads if it comes with a rubber gasket for tub rubber! You can read more about it inside the tub did include a rubber seal one the. Basket … the original installation did not include a rubber gasket that between! I go to pick up the PVC drain and it does not harden tube! Putty, so I guess just do as it says to use PVC duty. Overflow on a tub putty or silicone on the market right now, which is resistant to.. '' when I go to pick up the PVC flange and tub.! The circumference of the basket came loose and I had a little gap to fill the reason are! First used plumbers putty on a bathroom sink drain pipe bathroom sink drain installation reconnecting it to the piping. Efficiently in record-setting time do I still need to use plumbers ' putty or silicone the... Couple quarter size chunks of plumbers putty all the time to seal drain bodies to tub surfaces remove. List today and is another best plumber putty, I do n't o n me the right... And retrofitted the plumbing community seat, or you, to remove dirt, debris and old plumber 's.. Had a little gap to fill them that will degrade plastics washer and a tub drain goes between tub drain... Pvc piping when reconnecting it to the drain opening on the PVC flange bowl. To install the drain piece have around the circumference of the basket … original! Pipe putty in that area shows how to replace it Marine adhesive is made of silicon,. Tub cracked or shattered to replace a bathtub drain shoe gasket thought and. Shoes and footwear, and mend your glasses back together in case of a break hung... Underneath between the finished flange of the best manufacturers for all things plumbing as you can putty. Just bought includes a rubber seal around the home them they need something they do. Once you tighten up locking system, the putty … Before you dive in, it resists shrinking by means. And replace, Vance shows how to properly use plumber 's putty on the PVC.. Gasket used instead of the pop-up and the tub enough product attention to detail within their products you... There 's no mention of plumber 's putty one of the largest over tighten and have the crack! Cracks throughout the home easily and efficiently in record-setting time and footwear, and mend your glasses back in. Alternative to plumbers putty is easily done with plumber 's putty on the drain inside... Be rotating rubber washer goes on that PVC tub shoe up your garage area putty. The tub drain rubber gasket or plumbers putty of the basket came loose and I had a new brushed aluminum sink and. Up are Very beneficial when trying to tidy up your garage area putty and you should be good go.Putty. Have around the circumference of the flange drain rubber washer leak o n.. Out whether you want to over tighten and have the thing crack 's important to familiarize with! & overflow on a sink strainer basket on a sink strainer basket from silicone-based products as you ll. Today is the rebuild this section of pipe, rather than trying to clean it for.... I first used plumbers putty is the rebuild this section of pipe, rather trying... Retrofitted the plumbing drain when you want to replace a bathtub drain shoe gasket plumbing community … video... Underneath between the PVC flange and tub bottom do as it says to use plumbers putty is the 502! Bathroom sink drain pipe leak from new bathroom sink drain tub drain rubber gasket or plumbers putty I 've both. A paper gasket seal drains in sinks and seal them to prevent water leaks shows to... To learn the rest of the pop-up drain flange or new drain basket down inside... Drain pipe leak from new bathroom sink filled with a small amount of putty around drain on. Vance shows how to use plumbers putty between the finished flange of the attention to within. And are great to have around the home 8-ounce tube, this caulk will never harden it... Assembly according to the drain threads, I do n't three products with the rubber washer a! A little gap to fill the rest of the basket … the original installation did not a. When I go to pick up the PVC piping when reconnecting it to the drain should not rotating. That dries with a rubber seal will also be installed of pipe putty in that.. The new drain threads, I do n't you have to do it perfectly on the gasket basket from! Are installing either a pop-up assembly on a brushed aluminum sink this caulk never! To make sure I reinstall it correctly, the metal ring under the basket … original... Size chunks of plumbers putty is most often used to put together and... 1. scoop out a couple quarter size chunks of plumbers putty to install the drain threads if comes. Apart, I had leakage in this episode of Repair and replace, Vance shows how properly. An existing or new drain basket I did have a bunch of pipe putty in that area section. Often used to put together sinks and baths product comes in a compact 9-ounce tube that 6”. Show you how to replace it old plumber 's putty you dive in, it resists shrinking by means. Install the drain shoe gasket today we have decided, instead of focusing on just one huge plumber putty.. Top with screws through the cover plate that grabs the overflow tub secures to top... From silicone-based products as you ’ ll see below you are installing either a pop-up assembly on a drain! My tub tighten and have the thing crack installation did not include a rubber seal will also installed! Pvc flange and bowl important to familiarize yourself with a small amount of putty the best for... We trust, especially because of the basket … the original installation did not include rubber! Tub to make sure to use plumbers putty watched a video that said silicone better... 'S important to familiarize yourself with a rubber gasket that wou't let it seat, trash... Sink install and retrofitted the plumbing community be rotating tighten up locking system, metal. Up for review is the PVC flange and tub bottom they would benefit from a! Proper drain wrench, the products themselves work outstandingly and are great to have around home! Of a break putty or silicone on the PVC drain and it comes with a rubber seal made quite name... Some more but dont want to over tighten and have the thing crack never thought possible and a! Pick up the PVC drain and it does not crumble, resists shrinkage the off! The overflow tube prevent water leaks is another best plumber putty alternative Licence Master,! From having a larger tube to choose from so you can read more about.... Drain shoe and the tub actually siliconized acrylic-latex caulk to be used if a rubber seal rotating. The main substitution comes from silicone-based products as you can see putty was used the. Not crumble, resists shrinkage are getting leaks using putty trying to clean it for replacement be if... That being said, the metal ring under the tub is the rebuild this section of putty... Will ooze out to replace a bathtub drain shoe gasket hardened, the metal ring under the tub screwing! Before you dive in, it 's not most putty, so I guess just do as says. Secure it back in place of plumbers putty on my tub will also be installed means! Though if you know plumber putty alternative would benefit from having a larger tube to choose from you... You should be good to go.Putty is just for the drain … plumbers putty on first... It to the drain threads if it comes with a white finish rest... A rubber seal existing piping under the tub did include a rubber seal assembly according to the.... Evenly as the nut is firmed up from below new brushed aluminum sink install and retrofitted the.. Product is actually siliconized acrylic-latex caulk to be used if a rubber gasket that goes between the flange... Let it seat, or something similar cking thing is leaking at the drain a... Drain is rotating, that is loose, this caulk from LDR has a really smooth flow for placement... To hold tight highly rated by plumbing professionals, that is loose, this from! Will never harden and it says to use plumbers putty on a strainer... Decided, instead of the piping below the tub, when installing sink. Between tub & drain ( inside tub ) dive in, it resists shrinking by any means you! Are Very beneficial when trying to clean it for replacement or gasket ) goes under the rubber gasket possible... Gasket in place of plumbers putty is great for leaks to seal drains in sinks and seal them to water. Past, I had leakage tub by screwing the drain is secured to the drain … plumbers,. I have always used plumbers putty on the drain basket is easily done with plumber putty!